Evil: Who Wore it Best?

Image result for leviathan supernatural Image result for kyubey

Leviathans vs Kyubey.

Sometimes when I’m left alone with my own thoughts I go off on tangents that seem unrelated (and bit weird) on the surface, but make sense when given a little thought.

Aside from watching a fair bit of anime I have been slowly going through the Supernatural series. Currently I am somewhere near the end of the second season.

Last weekend I decided to re-watch Puella Magi Madoka Magica: Rebellion for no apparent reason (except that the Madoka series is one my favorite animes).

So, Monday morning, as I watched Supernatural and ate my breakfast, a thought occurred to me. The Leviathans on Supernatural and Kyubey (and the species of Incubators) are remarkably similar.

The thought came to me: They are both perceived as (and can be argued to be) evil. They, however, in both series can argue themselves to simply be pragmatists. Just doing what they need to do to survive.

Leviathans seek to fatten up the human race to use them as cattle for food. Incubators seek to use young teen girls as a power source that result in their death.

Now one may argue that the Leviathans are more evil because they want to eat everyone and that Incubators limit the damage: not so. Kyubey, by the end of the series, is looking forward to Madoka becoming the most powerful witch the world has ever seen, thus creating the largest source of power they’ve ever seen. BUT, her also becoming the most powerful witch also meant everyone on earth would be destroyed.  Kyubey viewed this as inconsequential, collateral damage.

Who is more morally corrupt? Leviathans or Incubators?

You may say: “But Incubators helped humans progress!!” True. Kyubey rationalized that the wishes they gave out helped forward humanity, thus they were being kind and treating humans well by allowing them to progress.

Image result for leviathan supernatural

Dick Roman, head Leviathan, also did things to “help” mankind. His agricultural company that he acquired  was tasked with making food additives (corn syrup, etc) safer and more healthy for people. His other companies were also acting to cure cancer and other diseases. Sure, it was also to make humans more tasty, but it was also done with the rationalization to “help” humanity.

Once again: Which is more evil? Still seems like a toss up.

There is also how they look:

Kyubey: Fluffy, cute, vacant eyes, weird ear thingys.

Image result for kyubey

Leviathans: Could be really anyone. The head one is Dick Roman. A handsome, well spoken, businessman/ humanitarian.
Related image

Well…Leviathans are pretty creepy when they eat! True… but so is Kyubey when they eat their own corpse.
Image result for kyubey eating himself gif

Waste not, want not…I guess?

What about the trope that evil never dies? True. Leviathans are really hard to kill. Borax…decapitation. And Dick Roman they needed a bone, 3 kinds of rare blood: very complicated.

Incubators on the other hand don’t seem to be able to die. This is never made clear. Homura does manage to traumatize the hell out Kyubey by the end of Rebellion though.

Related image


A final argument to say Incubators is less evil could be made suggesting that by the end of the original series that they are perfectly happy collecting energy via magical girls hunting wraiths. However, Rebellion nullifies this. The Incubators had trapped Homura before she became a witch and were seeing how they could harness they energy having her trapped in her own labyrinth. They were still basically seeing humans as lesser beings to be used as  a resource, much like Leviathans.

So…Who wore evil the best?

Was it evil?

This is what happens when the mind wanders.

Until next time: Happy viewing!


*images on this post are not owned by this blog*



6 thoughts on “Evil: Who Wore it Best?

  1. Karandi November 21, 2016 / 7:27 pm

    I like characters that are more ambiguous than just good or evil and Kyubey is a great example of one of these characters. I haven’t got far enough through Supernatural to have met the Leviathans yet but they sound fascinating so maybe I’ll have to hurry up and catch up with the series.
    Thanks for sharing.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Crystal November 28, 2016 / 4:43 am

    Really interesting question you’ve posed here. I think both are just as evil, but I will say the Incubators are far more off putting because they come to girls in the guise of cute animal side kick. There’s no sense of mistrust or doubt with them, until they reveal their game plan to Madoka later on. The Leviathans act like they’re doing all of these great things for humanity, but you always have that inkling in your mind that they aren’t quite right and something fishy is up, and it’s only a matter of time before the shoe drops. I guess that’ not a matter of who’s more evil, just who executes their plans more craftily.

    Really liked this post! I’ve watched all of Supernatural, and although the later seasons (I’d say after six or seven) go a little off the rails, it’s still enjoyable to watch. Hope you enjoy the show for the rest of your watch through.

    Liked by 1 person

    • madreceiver November 28, 2016 / 1:48 pm

      I’m on season 8 of Supernatural at the moment.
      I just was amused that both the Leviathans and Incubators were quite similar in their approach when I gave it a little thought. I guess they both kind of fall in that category of “Neutral Evil”.
      I’m glad you enjoyed the post!

      Liked by 1 person

  3. theanimeprince December 4, 2016 / 8:30 pm

    Dick killed my main man Bobby, so he wore being a “dick” best, at the very least.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s